|
“A perceptive and creative study of eastern German education.
The sections on Wolfgang Harich and of hopeful reformers among
the technical intelligentsia are very well done. I especially liked
the treatment of the World Youth Games, held in East Berlin in
1973, which I attended during my first trip to the GDR. The Games
were exactly as John Rodden describes them, with thousands of eager,
blue-shirted FDJ students swarming among the city. Oddly, Angela
Davis was the celebrity speaker for the event, who seemed at last
to have found a receptive audience for her tirades. — A.
James McAdams, Director, Nanovic Institute for European Studies,
University of Notre Dame.
“Because I was a professor during
the GDR era and contributed toward the formation of East German
education, I am thoroughly
familiar with the stories and events that John Rodden relates.
His book is fascinating, sometimes even thrilling to read, and
it addresses a public far beyond academic specialists. It is
accessible to the general reader and deserves the widest possible
audience. I have been most impressed by Rodden's scholarly expertise,
profound
philosophical grasp, and power of verbal and intellectual expression.
He has an unusual stance that is both sympathetic and critical
at the same time, and it facilitates his penetrating understanding
of the essential purposes and aspirations of GDR education and
cultural politics. I say all this as a man who himself lived
through most of the history of GDR educational and cultural politics, first
as a supporter of the regime and then, beginning in the mid-1980s,
increasingly in opposition to the dictatorship—and who
experienced the events of 1989-90 as a personal and intellectual
liberation
from an ideological straitjacket. I can, therefore, on the basis
of my own intimate knowledge of that history, evaluate with great
confidence the outstanding achievement of this book as a work
of scholarship and human empathy. This book exhibits an amazingly
detailed knowledge of the German situation, not just with regard
to its educational institutions but in its grasp of the entire
cultural and philosophical context of the former GDR and eastern
Europe.” — Wolfgang Strauss, University of Jena
“I simply cannot praise this book enough. It is a truly
impressive work. It is beautifully conceived and executed, as well
as intellectually and morally engaging. Above all, it is so very,
very well written with a lively style, a tempered wit, a remarkable
literary and historical erudition, and a refreshing human empathy.
The portraits are robust and dominant. I could swear that some
of Rodden’s conversation partners have crossed my path over
the years, under different names to be sure. This is the kind of
work that teachers can use in a seminar on recent German or European
history and politics. It will certainly stimulate interest and
discussion among all students in these areas.” — Christian
Soe, California State University at Long Beach
"Put Rodden's new book on education in East Germany, Textbook
Reds, next to his earlier one, Repainting the Little Red Schoolhouse,
and you have all the library you need to understand the dynamics
of the former German Democratic Republic, in every aspect, from
its beginning to its end. Not even more specialized studies
range as far and probe as deep, thanks to Rodden's astonishing
versatility as a historian. He moves deftly from analysis
of textbooks to personal interviews, from the teaching of the high-school
disciplines to the corruption and the cult of personality in the
GDR. The interviews bring an immediacy one seldom finds in
a book so scholarly, and the scholarship is thorough across a spectrum
of approaches. Make no mistake — using the educational
system as a starting point does not narrow the perspective but
opens out whole horizons instead. Comprehensive, brilliant,
and vivid." —Vincent Kling, La Salle University
“The scope of this book goes beyond previous investigations
of the subject, both in the sense of its comprehensive inclusiveness
of topics beyond education in narrowly conceived terms, and in
its extension of the historical narrative to post-GDR life. Never
before have the intricate interactions among educational programs,
ideological motivations, and the exigencies of practical politics
in the GDR been demonstrated so thoroughly and with such rich documentation.
Rodden’s illumination of the interconnections among educational
programming, social engineering, and political power make this
study a significant contribution not just to German studies, but
to the sociology of nation-building as well. But this work does
not merely demonstrate the centrality of education to Marxist nation
building, it also shows the reasons and conditions leading to the
successive failures and ultimate undoing of this communist project.
One of the most appealing features of Textbook Reds is Rodden’s
lively, witty, and forceful writing style. This style is thoroughly
compatible with the book’s sound scholarship, because it
serves to highlight his basic themes by giving dramatic power to
various anecdotes, personal encounters, and historical scenes.
Most engaging is Rodden’s very personal viewpoint in his
portraits of the East Germans that he interviewed. His vignettes
show vividly the fateful determination of German lives by history,
and the poignant, sometimes humorous tone brings his nuanced yet
sympathetic American perspective into the foreground, often mitigating
the gloom and endowing the tragedy with promise and hope.” — Walter
Sokel, University of Virginia
“This book makes a valuable contribution to our understanding
of the functioning of dictatorship as well as to the general processes
of social change. I am most impressed by the beautiful essayistic
style and sovereign command of German jokes, conversational language,
and everyday slang. This is an excellent book that will be of great
value to the scholar and general reader alike.”
—
Karl-Heinz Fuessl, Institute for Education and History, Humboldt
University, Berlin
“This stimulating book is written with grace. It is a fascinating
portrait gallery of GDR life. I was particularly intrigued with
the latter material given my extensive contact with GDR citizens
from 1988 on.” — Randall Bytwerk, Calvin College
If one wants to know what children in communist East Europe
were told to think about their nation and their leaders, their
class
enemy, and their so-called Soviet friends, no better source exists
than textbooks. In textbooks the dogmas of communism were communicated
in their most simplified form and manufactured in the millions
for
mass consumption. In Textbook Reds, John Rodden shows
how the now-defunct German Democratic Republic (GDR) shaped generations
of East German youth and how the imprint of Marxist-Leninist
ideology
remains today on the hearts and minds of millions of eastern
Germans, more than fifteen years after the fall of the Berlin
Wall.
Drawing on a rich and varied collection
of materials—a total
of more than 200 textbooks, teaching guides, school songbooks, educators’
professional journals, and school examinations—Rodden shows
the “textbook mentality” that permeated East German
society. In the GDR’s campaign to win the minds of men, any
critiques of the Party were equated with disloyalty and the bourgeois
sins of individualism, negativism, and cosmopolitanism. Citizens
who broke free of such indoctrination still bore marks of its influence,
even long after leaving school—and long after the GDR’s
dissolution in 1990.
The second part of the book offers a glimpse of post-communism
today. Through interviews with dozens of teachers and students
from contemporary
eastern Germany, we see that East German faculty and students
constitute perhaps the largest, most articulate, most traumatized
segment of
the population affected by events since 1989.
Not just a study in comparative education, Textbook Reds is
also a work in the sociology of education, literary sociology,
and literary history. Rodden shows that the deepest roots of
GDR
society were indeed located in the institution that molded the
youth of its citizens, and that the most searching questions
about East
German identity and the repression of its political past are
in fact to be found there.
|
|
|